Eschalon: Book I Reviews

Eschalon: Book I presents an intriguing premise that could have captivated modern players. However, the game suffers from the passage of time in several key areas. The interface is clunky and lacks adequate scaling options, making it feel dated. Additionally, the mechanics and overall gameplay can feel archaic, and the writing often comes across as amateurish, detracting from the experience. Graphically, while the visuals are decent, the heavy reuse of assets creates a repetitive feel throughout the game. In isolation, Eschalon might seem acceptable, but when compared to its peers or later titles it inspired, like Balrum or Exiled Kingdoms (which I strongly recommend), it becomes clear that it falls short. There are certainly commendable ideas present, such as the cartography system and the ability to hide in the dark, which add depth to the gameplay. However, the main plot remains elusive, and the sparse number of NPCs makes the world feel empty and less engaging. Walking across the map can feel long and tiresome, leading to a sense of fatigue rather than adventure. Ultimately, while Eschalon: Book I has its moments, I find it difficult to recommend it to contemporary players looking for a rich and immersive experience. There are simply too many areas where the game doesn’t hold up against more modern offerings, or older games like Fallout 1 & 2, Wizardry, Ultima etc...