Phantom Alchemy ~Silvia's Dynamic Urban Planning~ Reviews

This is a great game to learn all about the secret art of alchemy and what the female alchemists had to do, to get all the bodily fluids necessary to build a whole town. I would never had known if not for this game. Now I see my hometown in a whole different light too. Thank you developers.

So, I read the reviews for this and bought it anyway. Don't make the mistake I did. Yes, it's a low end version of Brave Alchemist Colette. But I thought that just being a knock off would mean that it can't be that bad. Spoilers, it is. It's just a bad game. The story is bad, whatever mechanics in it are bad, and the H scenes are just ok at best. If you haven't played Colette, go do that. If you like Colette and want something along the same lines, it's not this. If you find something like Colette but good, let me know. But this isn't it.

This is... odd. I'll preface this with the fact that the game is REALLY good - in it's own right, I can't bring any complaints against it. The problem is that, in effect, this game has been done before - in Brave Alchemist Colette, and BAC does everything this game does plus significantly more, and better. The MCs even have a similar appearance (not a bad thing) and the premise for the H is identical. (Though the main storyline is admittedly quite different but the stakes are far lower.) The problem here isn't that there is anything wrong or even bad about the game, it's just that practically every aspect gets overshadowed by BAC. I gave this the thumbs up, and I don't feel bad about doing so, because this game IS good, and if HRPGs are something you enjoy you'll get your money's worth here; but I would be remiss if I didn't say that if you want a HRPG and this one tempts you, you'd be better off getting BAC instead (if you don't already have it). 7/10

No thanks. Story - you get sold by your father to pay for his crime, sold in to slavery, forced to have relationships and at the same time follow a very linear story of going out gathering ingredients, making stuff through alchemy and fighting demons and minions (because no-one in the world is powerful enough, not even at the adventures guild, except a xxx slave!!). No imagination in the story at all. Art work is okay, not many scenes at all and majority of them can be unlocked by chatting to someone in the recollection room. If you have Brave Alchemist Collette - re-play that it's 110% better, if you haven't placed Brave Alchemist Collette, go buy it.

[h1] This is just a Walmart version of Brave Alchemist Colette. [/h1]I Just in case you still want to buy this game. The main girl is fully voiced. The art is good but only still image. You got Rxped in the first scene and there is no virgin route. All the game concept is same as Brave Alchemist Colette, just worst. I really cannot recommend this game.