Making History: The Great War Reviews

Gameplay Mechanics: 10/10 Narrative: 6/10 Graphics: 6/10 Sound and Music: 6/10 Replayability: 8/10 Innovation: 7/10 Making History: The Great War nails what it sets out to do—a slow-burning, detailed grand strategy game that captures the complex, grinding nature of World War I. It’s not flashy, but it’s one of the most mechanically rich and accurate WWI strategy experiences out there. Gameplay mechanics are a standout. This is where the game really shines. You’re managing production chains, building up infrastructure, balancing trade, planning military unit development, and orchestrating large-scale mobilization over time. It’s a true logistics-and-planning simulator. The turn-based design gives you time to weigh your options carefully, and everything from naval convoys to trench warfare has meaningful depth. Score: 10/10. Narrative is pretty light. The game provides a historical setup with accurate borders, alliances, and tensions, but it doesn’t guide you through a scripted storyline or major event chains. It’s a sandbox through and through—what story emerges is entirely based on your actions. Score: 6/10. Graphics are basic. The world map is easy to read, and unit icons are clear, but it all feels a bit dated. It’s functional and clean, just not visually impressive by today’s standards. Score: 6/10. Sound and music are fine but forgettable. The soundtrack fits the tone, and the effects are serviceable. There’s nothing jarring, but nothing particularly memorable either. Score: 6/10. Replayability is strong. You can take control of any number of nations, from global powers to regional underdogs, and each offers a different strategic challenge. Combined with the open-ended structure, you’ll get a lot of mileage if you enjoy trying different economic and military paths. Score: 8/10. Innovation is solid. The game takes the Making History framework and does a good job adjusting it to the unique tempo and nature of WWI. The emphasis on long-term logistics, morale, and slow-moving front lines feels appropriate and adds unique tension. Score: 7/10. In short, Making History: The Great War is a must-play for strategy fans looking for a detailed, historically grounded WWI sandbox. It’s all about planning, patience, and depth—and it does that better than almost any other title in its niche.