Playtime:
514 minutes
Red Johnson's Chronicles: A budget detective adventure game with mostly mixed reviews, and for good reason, as it mostly leaves me with mixed feelings.
This is a 2-in-1 pack of detective games, and contains a launcher for two totally separate episodes. Set in a rundown, crime-ridden big city, our protagonist is a skilled but insufferably cocky private eye who frequently solves crimes for the local cops. In the first episode, he is contracted by a bumbling patrolman to solve a random murder that may be connected to the recent prison escape of a notorious thief. In the second episode, a criminal mastermind puts a bounty on Red's head as he searches for his missing brother. Each episode takes roughly 4-5 hours to complete. Tonally, the game is very comic-book-noire; it's a serious mystery but filled with wacky offbeat characters that prevent it from being too serious.
As I am writing this, Red Johnson came out almost seven years ago and has fewer than 20 reviews on Steam. I liked the look of it, though, so I gambled and picked it up on deep discount at 99 cents. I definitely feel like I got my money's worth, but I also feel like there are plenty of better mysteries and adventures that you could be spending your time with; while there are definitely positives with this game, they are ultimately outweighed by the negatives.
Here are the positives: Aesthetically, Red Johnson is pretty good! The visuals in Red Johnson are quite nice, from its filthy streets to its cluttered indoor environments. I have no complaints about the environments, character models, or animations. The game's voice actors also cast well and do a fine job in carrying the story. Red Johnson also goes out of its way to really add variety to the gameplay. Puzzles are varied and include inventory puzzles, finding hidden collectibles, examining and comparing evidence, mechanical puzzles, dialog puzzles, even making police sketches based on descriptions.
The stories are solidly decent - not spectacular, but also not at all bad, and they were enjoyable enough to keep me playing. It is not where the main problems with this game lie, and if you like a good mystery story, you might still enjoy the game IF you have the patience to deal with some super frustrating mechanics.
There are two major negatives in my view which prevent me from recommending the game. First is the uneven game design combined with how the game treats failure. Puzzle difficulty is all over the map and ranges from trivial to impossible; sometimes objectives are extremely unclear. There is a hint system, but it's irritating, patronizing, and also costs in-game currency to use. Furthermore, there's QTEs all over the place. Dialogue puzzles sometimes require you to make wild guesses or to remember very specific details. With each puzzle, QTE, or conversation, you are always given a grade afterwards, based on time taken, hints used, and number of mistakes and if you're me, that grade is frequently not great. It autosaves over itself like crazy, too, so no save scumming allowed. The whole thing adds this crazy level of stress to what should be a nice casual experience, and punishes you for failure or even just taking a few seconds too long.
The other major problem is the game's control scheme. Other reviewers mention it, but it truly is bonkers. It's not remappable, and consists of mouse+spacebar and the V, B, and N keys. And the mouse is not just click-based, there's tons of things where you need to click and also do gestures like sliding or rotating or rapidly shaking. The sensitivity for the mouse is also extremely problematic, and while lowering my mouse DPI helped a lot, it would still misregister gestures during QTEs a lot (causing failure) or make me spin my mouse in little circles for 45 seconds like a madman to lower a windowshade pixel by pixel or some such puzzle nonsense.
All in all, Red Johnson is okay, but will require dealing with some pretty serious frustrations to get real enjoyment out of it. For adventure games with a similar vibe, I would instead recommend Chicken Police or Cognition: An Erica Reed Thriller.
👍 : 8 |
😃 : 0