Town of Salem 2 Reviews

perty good!

Gamble time ended... give me my Gamba time back :c

The mechanics and the UI interface was better built in this game compared to TOS1. Though the game has a unique charm of being a good place to start to learn the game whereas TOS1 has it's charm for being more difficult and challenging to learn for beginners.

Fantastic game, my favorite of all time probably. Hard to learn, but incredible once you understand it. If you are into social deduction games, it's a great pick.

The only game where you can assasinate a political figure, then proceed to burn to death at the same time.

dead as hell not fun, folks optimized the fun out genuinely amazing

People ONLY play All Any. If you're new its so hard to learn the game because of this difficult mode. edit: ranked is empty too. pointless :/

I liked the game but the devs are makeing very bad choices and I dont recommend supporting a now mostly micro trasantion, pay to win game.

A great game, ruined by an awfull developer who does not deserve to exist anymore. After causing the worst dataleak I have been a part of, leaking passwords that were secured far below what is acceptable (MD5, not bcrypt or something made for it) they decided to ruin the game and playerbase banning people for bad reasons (I have not been, but seen it happen) and removing the free play on browser. The browser is what made it popular. I spent so much time playing TOS 1 on a browser at school. Honestly, someone needs to re-make a game almost like this, and manage it will. It should do very well.

[h3]Stay away for now...[/h3][hr][/hr][i]I truly wanted to love Town of Salem 2—just as I did its predecessor. This game had so much potential to thrive, yet the direction the developers chose has been deeply disheartening. Rather than embracing the dedicated modding community that sought to enrich the experience, they prioritized a questionable publishing partnership while aggressively monetizing content. [b]Over time, my passion for this game has faded—not just because of its design flaws, but also due to the increasingly difficult, arrogant, unwelcoming, harsh, and toxic community atmosphere. At times, I feel like I’m the only girl who truly carries a sense of humanity and empathy. It feels as though I’m one of the few who truly understand how disheartening and discouraging this environment can be. At the time of writing, the game is in the weakest state it has been since its launch. Instead of meaningful updates, the only consistent additions are paid cosmetics—while the ranked mode remains stagnant and underpopulated. Worse, the two newly introduced roles disrupt game balance in a way that feels frustrating rather than engaging.[/b] When compared to the original Town of Salem, this sequel feels like a rushed mix of ideas that never quite come together. New players, unless they are willing to invest hundreds of hours (as I did in ToS 1), will likely feel lost from the moment they start. The game does little to guide them, and the overwhelming number of mechanics can make the experience feel more punishing than rewarding.[hr][/hr]From the very start, the experience feels needlessly complicated. Before even stepping into a match, you must create an account and navigate an outdated UI to decorate a personal “home”—a feature that serves no real purpose other than as another grind (or, perhaps, a future monetization avenue). This mechanic, seemingly repurposed from Traitors of Salem, adds little to the actual gameplay experience. Finding a match can also be frustrating. Attempting to queue for "Classic" mode—designed to be a simple introduction to the game—often results in an absurd wait, with no indication of when the lobby will fill. In reality, Classic games are rarely accessible, forcing most players into the only truly active mode: All Any. All Any throws players into a chaotic mix of 61 roles spread across seven factions, with neutral roles that operate solo, often feeling isolated. This can make learning the game incredibly overwhelming, as understanding fake claims, role interactions, and faction dynamics takes significant time. Even as a longtime ToS 1 player, I struggled for hours before I felt remotely competent in this mode. This lack of accessible game modes also makes ranked nearly impossible to experience. To even qualify for ranked matches, you must first complete ten ranked practice games—but good luck finding any. In fact, I have yet to see a full lobby, and those that do start often see players drop out the moment they realize how empty it is. In ToS 1, ranked was lively, with a strong player base. A well-designed progression system with meaningful rewards could have helped retain players, but the developers have ignored this entirely. At its core, Town of Salem 2 no longer feels like a truly immersive social deduction game. Matches often end in one-sided eliminations, and recent role additions have only exacerbated the imbalance. The developers’ attempt to dismantle old strategies, such as the "Jailor meta," led to new roles specifically designed to hunt down revealed players. Despite these struggles, I still love the essence of Town of Salem. The concept, the intrigue, the mind games—it’s all there, waiting for the right execution. But I can’t, in good faith, recommend this game to most players. Unless you’re already a dedicated fan of social deduction games or have extensive experience with ToS 1, it’s difficult to find enjoyment here without feeling overwhelmed. The game does little to teach new players the necessary knowledge, and unfortunately, the community itself can be quite unforgiving toward mistakes. This, combined with the game’s increased complexity, makes it harder for newcomers to find their footing. While Classic Mode does offer a slightly gentler learning curve, it remains difficult to access due to matchmaking issues. Another heartbreaking reality is the game’s dwindling player base. ToS 2 rarely exceeds 1,000 concurrent players, and since they are spread across multiple modes, you often run into the same people repeatedly. Social deduction games thrive on an active community. Seeing this game struggle, when it once had such promise, is truly disappointing. This could have been something special. The potential for Town of Salem 2 to surpass games like Among Us or even Clue in depth and engagement was absolutely there. But without modern features—such as seasonal events, guilds, ranked incentives, an improved UI, and stable matchmaking—the game has struggled to grow. That said, if you still decide to give it a try, I strongly recommend checking out the BToS2 mod. It embodies everything Town of Salem 2 could have been—a true love letter to the game’s social deduction roots.[hr][/hr]There was a time when I adored this game with all my heart, supporting it wholeheartedly and cherishing every moment it brought me. But with the arrival of Town of Salem 2 (ToS2), something precious has been lost. The magic that once made this game so special has faded. If you’re thinking about supporting ToS2, I encourage you to pause for a moment and consider the journey this game has taken. The most painful of all is how moderation is handled. I share my thoughts not out of anger, but out of love—for the game it once was and for the community that deserves so much better. My hope is to help others make an informed decision. The moderation and development team has been actively removing critical posts from Reddit, Discord, and Steam—often with vague accusations of "harassment". Emily even shared proof of these deletions through an Imgur link, yet Digital Bandidos dismissed the evidence as "misinformation." One heartfelt review on Steam, written by a user named Emily, shares a deeply personal experience and has resonated with many. At the time of writing, it’s the "most helpful" review, with 185 players supporting her words. If you have a moment, I encourage you to read it and listen to these voices. Despite the growing concerns, the moderation team insists that these criticisms are unfounded. But when transparency is missing, it’s difficult not to see the cracks in the system. Even more troubling, some players have been banned from ToS2 without warning—simply for voicing concerns or offering constructive criticism. It’s heartbreaking to see a community silenced for speaking the truth. No one should be punished for expressing genuine concerns, especially when it comes from a place of care and dedication. While they may try to erase these conversations from their platforms, they cannot erase the stories shared in Steam reviews. The truth is there for those willing to listen. I know that by writing this, I may be putting myself at risk of being silenced as well. But I cannot stand by and watch dedicated players be treated unfairly. I believe in fairness, in honesty, and in holding people accountable for how they treat others. Time has a way of revealing the truth. You cannot erase what has already been done, nor rewrite the experiences of those who have been hurt. I have seen how this community has been treated—how innocent people have been cast aside simply for speaking out. And I will not turn a blind eye. Not here, not anywhere, whether in a game, in a forum or in life. If you are new to this game, I urge you to take a moment to learn about its history before making your decision. I do not write this out of bitterness, but out of love—for the game that once was and for the people who deserved so much better.[/i]